John Cage’s body of work has often been used to “define what constitutes “experimental” music in the broadest sense. This has worked to deny the influence of comparably innovative music practices by women and people of colour” (Rodgers, T. 2010, pg 10; Oliveros, P. 1984)
Cage places an “emphasis in experimental music on operational processes, which ensure a music that appears to happen of its own accord, unassisted by a master hand, as if thrown up by natural forces.” (see: Nyman, 2010, pg 26).
“Thus, despite Cage’s own efforts to disrupt hegemonic silences, the centrality of his work in subsequent electronic and experimental music histories has often had the effect of silencing others. Moreover, the process-oriented compositional strategies advanced by Cage that seek to erase or reduce the influence of a composer’s intent on the resulting music can be interpreted as a negation of identity; this may not be a universally desirable aesthetic for artists of historically marginalized groups who have suffered the effects of imposed forms of silencing and erasure. Indeed, feminists have often located empowerment within acts of breaking silences, by foregrounding aspects of identity.” – Rodgers, T. (2010) Pink Noises. pg 10).
Pauline Oliveros, while admired as a key figure in the development and innovation of experimental – is often isolated and thus tokenised, featured often as the “only woman in textbooks that otherwise cover a variety of men’s work in detail.” (Rodgers, T, 2010, pg 11).
Oliveros’ work ‘Sound Patterns’ fulfills criteria of experimental music partly in its use of extended vocal techniques. Extended vocal techniques followed on from Dada, post-war surrealism and the avant-garde and involve using the voice in unexpected and unusual ways. Another parallel between Cage and Oliveros: heavily influenced by surrealism and the philosophies of of Dada, “Cage utilized the voice in his later compositions as a vehicle of sound, not necessarily beauty” (Crump, M.A. 2008. pg 38).
Oliveros’ use of extended vocal techniques in this piece for a cappella mixed chorus is understood to reflect her interest in electronic music at the time, reflected in works such as ‘Time Perspectives’ (Oliveros, 1961) for tape. The parallels between these two works in composition are numerous. They both involve a broad range of sounds, and use the full range of the voice. They both use moments of silence, as well as using interruptions of sound to fill silences. There is a broad dynamic range and they are composed of often non-tonal sounds rather than being musical.
Both pieces demonstrate experimental composers’ interest in “the prospect of outlining a situation in which sounds may occur”, rather than “prescribing a defined time-object whose materials, structuring and relationships are calculated and arranged in advance” and in the ways in which “relations […] exist between sounds as they would exist between people [these relationships] are more complex than [one] would be able to prescribe.” The performance of ‘Sound Patterns’ or ‘Time Perspectives’ would be difficult to reproduce exactly, and would involve improvised decisions in the moment of performance (another of Nyman’s conditions of experimental music).
References:
Rodgers, T. (2010) Pink Noises: Women on Sound and Electronic Music. Durham: Duke University Press.
Oliveros, P. (1984, 2015) SOFTWARE FOR PEOPLE – COLLECTED WRITINGS 1963 – 1980. Second Edition.
Nyman, M. [1974] (1999) “Towards a definition of Experimental Music”. Experimental Music: Cage and Beyond.
Crump, M.A., 2008. When words are not enough: tracing the development of extended vocal techniques in twentieth-century America (Doctoral dissertation, University of North Carolina at Greensboro).
Oliveros, P. (1961) Time Perspectives [online]. Massachusetts: Imprec. Available at: https://imprec.bandcamp.com/album/pauline-oliveros-reverberations-tape-electronic-music-1960-1970-12cd
Oliveros, P. (2015). The Difference between Hearing and Listening | Pauline Oliveros | TEDxIndianapolis. YouTube. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_QHfOuRrJB8.